I have almost got the gist of my story and it WILL include another character. This character will act as a helper/rescuer, I didn't want my character to be handsome and charming, so I made them quirky instead.
I like numbers 2 - He's cute and I think it fits into the cartoon, child audience more as its an animal.
Number 5 - As he looks average and the antlers and a quirkiness that I like, it also suggests hes not fully human.
Number 8 - I think this one looks the most human, apart from the elf ears. I like that its primp and neat.